CAT 1 vs. CAT M1 vs. NB-IoT: Best for Raspberry Pi Industry

Industrial IoT systems increasingly depend on reliable cellular connectivity to deliver real-time data, enable remote control, and ensure continuous operation. When integrating cellular modules with platforms such as the Raspberry Pi, engineers must carefully evaluate which communication standard – CAT 1, CAT M1, or NB-IoT – best aligns with their application’s speed, power, mobility, and coverage requirements.

This blog provides a comprehensive technical comparison of these three technologies, specifically in the context of Raspberry Pi–based industrial deployments, which often use hardware such as 4G LTE CAT 1 HATs, EC200U modules, or other cellular modems.

1. Overview of Cellular Technologies for IoT

To choose the right technology, it is important to understand the fundamental characteristics:

1. 4G LTE CAT 1

A widely deployed cellular standard offering moderate speed, full mobility, and good coverage. It supports both voice and data, making it suitable for medium-bandwidth industrial IoT.

2. LTE CAT M1 (LTE-M)

A low-power, wide-area (LPWA) technology optimized for IoT. It reduces energy consumption, extends battery life, and supports mobility, though speeds are lower compared to CAT 1.

3. NB-IoT

A narrowband LPWA technology focused on extremely low power and deep indoor penetration. It is ideal for low-bandwidth, infrequent communication but does not support mobility and has limited throughput.

2. Technical Comparison Table

Feature	CAT 1	CAT M1 (LTE-M)	NB-IoT
Bandwidth	~5–10 Mbps downlink	Up to 1 Mbps	26–100 Kbps
Latency	Low (30–50 ms)	Moderate (50–150 ms)	High (1–10 sec)
Mobility Support	Full mobility	Supports mobility	No mobility
Power Usage	Medium	Low	Very Low
Coverage	Normal LTE coverage	Extended vs LTE	Deep indoor coverage
Use Cases	Gateways, cameras, robots	Wearables, industrial nodes	Meters, sensors
Module Cost	Medium	Medium/Low	Low
Network Availability (India)	Widely available	Limited but growing	Available from select operators

3. Industrial Requirements and How Each Technology Performs

3.1 Bandwidth Needs

Industrial applications such as SCADA monitoring, edge gateways, RS-485 data acquisition, or remote PLC access may require moderate bandwidth.

CAT 1 supports video uploads, large data packets, and parallel cloud traffic.
CAT M1 handles sensor data and control commands efficiently.
NB-IoT struggles with high-frequency or large payload transfers.

Summary: If your Raspberry Pi is acting as a gateway or transferring logs, CAT 1 is the best match.

3.2 Latency and Real-Time Performance

Certain industrial tasks – like alarms, actuator control, and MQTT telemetry – depend on low latency.

CAT 1 provides stable real-time responsiveness.
CAT M1 is acceptable for periodic or semi-real-time tasks.
NB-IoT may introduce multi-second delays, unsuitable for time-critical operations.

Summary: For real-time industrial control, CAT 1 or CAT M1 is preferred.

3.3 Power Consumption

Power usage influences long-term field deployments, especially when running off batteries or solar power.

CAT M1 and NB-IoT are optimized for low-power modes like PSM and eDRX.
CAT 1 consumes more power and generally requires a stable supply.

Summary: For battery-powered sensors, NB-IoT or CAT M1 provides significantly longer life.

3.4 Mobility and Device Movement

Moving robots, AGVs, and vehicle-mounted Raspberry Pi systems need stable handovers.

CAT 1 supports seamless mobility across LTE cells.
CAT M1 supports handover but with more restrictions.
NB-IoT does not support mobility – connection drops during movement.

Summary: For mobile industrial systems or vehicle IoT, CAT 1 is the only viable option.

3.5 Network Availability in Real Deployments

In many countries, including India, CAT 1 is fully supported, while CAT M1 and NB-IoT availability varies by operator.

CAT 1 – Fully available across all 4G networks.
CAT M1 – Partial rollout, not supported by all operators.
NB-IoT – Deployed selectively, often limited to smart metering projects.

Summary: For guaranteed connectivity, CAT 1 is the safest choice with Raspberry Pi deployments.

4. Application Suitability

CAT 1 – Best For

Industrial IoT Gateways: Raspberry Pi gateways can aggregate multi-protocol field data and push it to cloud or on-premise platforms, making CAT 1 ideal for medium-bandwidth, always-connected systems.
Remote Monitoring and Diagnostics: CAT 1 supports continuous data transmission for SCADA logs, PLC values, and machine health parameters without latency limitations.
Edge Computing Workloads: Raspberry Pi units performing local analytics, filtering, or AI inference require stable connectivity, which CAT 1 provides through consistent upstream and downstream bandwidth.
Surveillance and Imaging Devices: Applications involving image uploads, camera snapshots, or periodic video frames depend on CAT 1’s higher throughput capabilities.
Mobile Industrial Systems: AGVs, robots, and vehicle-mounted Raspberry Pi units need full mobility support, which CAT 1 delivers through seamless LTE cell handovers.
Modbus/RS-485 to Cloud Gateways: When used with RS-485 interfaces, CAT 1 enables real-time transmission of sensor and controller data to platforms like AWS or Azure without connection drops.

CAT M1 – Best For

Battery-Powered Industrial Sensors: Devices requiring long-term operation benefit from CAT M1’s low-power modes such as PSM and eDRX, reducing energy consumption significantly.
Portable Diagnostic Tools: Handheld devices using Raspberry Pi for data logging or testing can transmit results efficiently using CAT M1’s moderate data speeds and lower current draw.
Logistics and Asset Tracking: Mobile tracking units benefit from CAT M1’s extended coverage and low-bandwidth efficiency, allowing consistent updates without draining battery life.
Periodic Telemetry Applications: Systems that send sensor values or equipment status at fixed intervals can utilize CAT M1’s optimized uplink performance.
Wide-Area Industrial Coverage: Remote factories or outdoor installations benefit from CAT M1’s extended range compared to traditional LTE networks.

NB-IoT – Best For

Utility and Smart Metering: NB-IoT’s narrowband operation supports ultra-low data rates suited for electricity, water, or gas meters reporting a few times per day.
Environmental Monitoring Nodes: Sensors measuring temperature, gas concentration, air quality, or environmental events benefit from NB-IoT’s long battery life and deep penetration.
Fixed, Non-Mobile Installations: NB-IoT lacks mobility support, making it ideal for stationary devices embedded in walls, basements, or industrial shafts.
Long-Interval Communication: Systems requiring hourly or daily updates operate efficiently on NB-IoT’s low-speed architecture.
High-Density Deployments: Industrial clusters with thousands of nodes can utilize NB-IoT’s narrowband spectrum to reduce network congestion and improve reliability.

5. Choosing the Right Technology for Raspberry Pi Industrial Projects

CAT 1

High data throughput requirements: Applications involving image transfer, large data logs, or continuous telemetry rely on CAT 1’s ability to maintain multi-Mbps connections.
Real-time control and automation: Low latency enables CAT 1 to support actuator control, robotics coordination, and SCADA-level responsiveness.
Full network mobility: Systems that move across facilities or geographic regions depend on CAT 1’s robust cell handover capabilities.
Guaranteed operator coverage: CAT 1 benefits from universal LTE availability, ensuring consistent performance across industrial sites.
Gateway-level computing: Raspberry Pi devices aggregating RS-485, CAN, or Ethernet data into MQTT/HTTP streams require CAT 1’s stable connection profile.

CAT M1

Power-sensitive Raspberry Pi solutions: Projects where Pi operates in optimized low-power states can leverage CAT M1 to reduce overall energy consumption.
Moderate data workloads: Telemetry, diagnostics, and status updates fit well within CAT M1’s ~1 Mbps bandwidth capabilities.
Medium-range industrial deployments: CAT M1 offers extended LTE coverage, suitable for factories located in remote or semi-urban regions.
Battery-assisted mobile equipment: Portable devices requiring mobility but low power benefit from CAT M1’s lower modem consumption.
Failover connectivity: CAT M1 can serve as a backup communication channel where CAT 1 is unavailable or overloaded.

NB-IoT

Ultra-low power IoT nodes: NB-IoT’s PSM and eDRX modes enable sensors to operate for years on small batteries.
Minimal data payloads: Applications sending only a few bytes periodically – like alarms, counters, or meter readings – fit NB-IoT’s design.
Deep indoor industrial environments: NB-IoT penetrates concrete, metal, and underground spaces where LTE signals may fail.
Geo-static installations: Devices that do not move benefit from NB-IoT’s coverage consistency despite lacking handover support.
High-volume deployments: Smart city, utility, and industrial sensor grids can scale cost-effectively using NB-IoT’s low-bandwidth channels.

Need the right connectivity for your Raspberry Pi industrial project?

Conclusion

Selecting the right cellular technology is essential for designing reliable and scalable industrial IoT systems built on Raspberry Pi. While CAT M1 and NB-IoT offer strong advantages in low power consumption and deep indoor coverage, CAT 1 remains the most deployment-ready and consistently supported option for industrial environments.

With widespread network availability, stable bandwidth, low latency, and full mobility support, CAT 1 is the most practical choice for Raspberry Pi – based industrial applications, especially when using hardware such as the Raspberry Pi 4G LTE CAT 1 HAT for continuous data acquisition, RS-485 gateway functions, SCADA reporting, or cloud communication.

For extremely low-data or battery-powered devices, CAT M1 or NB-IoT may still be suitable; however, they fit best with lightweight sensor nodes rather than high-performance computing units. When engineers require dependable connectivity, real-time responsiveness, and seamless integration with industrial protocols, CAT 1 paired with a Raspberry Pi 4G LTE CAT 1 HAT offers the optimal balance of performance, reliability, and field readiness.

FAQs

1. Which cellular standard is best suited for Raspberry Pi in industrial environments?

CAT 1 is the most suitable option for Raspberry Pi–based systems because it offers stable bandwidth, low latency, full mobility, and broad network availability. It supports real-time data transmission and works reliably for industrial gateways, automation systems, and remote monitoring.

2. Can CAT M1 or NB-IoT be used directly with Raspberry Pi?

Yes, but with limitations. While compatible modules exist for CAT M1 and NB-IoT, these technologies are optimized for low-power, low-bandwidth sensor devices. Their reduced throughput and higher latency make them less suitable for Raspberry Pi applications that require continuous data exchange, multi-device integration, or real-time communication.

3. What are the primary differences between CAT 1, CAT M1, and NB-IoT in terms of performance?

CAT 1: Moderate bandwidth (~10 Mbps), low latency, good mobility
CAT M1: Lower bandwidth (~1 Mbps), moderate latency, efficient power usage
NB-IoT: Very low bandwidth (<100 Kbps), high latency, deep indoor coverage

These differences directly affect application performance, especially for industrial control and gateway functions.

4. Is NB-IoT suitable for mobile Raspberry Pi applications like AGVs or vehicle-mounted systems?

No. NB-IoT does not support mobility and loses connection when the device moves between cells. Applications involving vehicles, robots, or portable equipment should use CAT 1, which handles seamless mobility and handover.

5. How do power requirements differ across CAT 1, CAT M1, and NB-IoT?

CAT 1 consumes the most power and requires a stable supply.
CAT M1 offers significantly lower power consumption due to optimized features such as PSM and eDRX.
NB-IoT delivers the lowest power usage, supporting multi-year battery life in static devices.

For Raspberry Pi systems, which already need consistent power, CAT 1 is typically the most appropriate.

Evaluating CAT 1 vs. CAT M1 vs. NB-IoT for Raspberry Pi – Based Industrial Applications Leave a comment